Pinoy Dream Academy’s Tenth Batch of Probationary Scholars

Posted November 11th, 2006
Visited 5413 times, 2 so far today


This week’s Probationary Scholars:

Joan Ilagan
Joan Ilagan

jay r siaboc
Jay-R Siaboc

davey langit
Davey Langit

irish fullerton
Irish Fullerton

EW! ABS-CBN made a concession to have Rosita sing a jukebox song while the rest of scholars sang rock songs. Obvious ba? YUCK! YUCK! YUCK!

Anyhow, I think the voters will save either Irish or Jay-R. The teachers will save either Jay-R or Joan. And the scholars? Who the f*ck knows what they will do this week.


Related Articles:

46 Comments

  1. cici20 said:

    “And the scholars? Who the f*ck knows what they will do this week.”
    Hahahhhaha… Chika, you’re funny!!!

  2. Dubai Rulez said:

    bat ganon?
    Mas mataas ang grado ni Rosita kesa kay Yeng?
    Yeng got 7.something and rosita got 8.something,
    and why the hell this judges voted Jay-R na sobrang taas ng tono ang kinanta (Note it: Jet Pangan)Bilang lang ang nakakakanta ng salamat ni Jet pangan na walang gaanong struggle.. and Rosita still the star dahil sa pinagdaanan nyang hirap hindi dahil sa performance nya.. dapat pala ang mga scholar na sumali dyan e ung mga mahihirap na tao pra kaawaan.!
    Shit!
    Ewan ko ba!
    no choice talga eh!
    kailangan manood ng TFC.

  3. andre said:

    tamo kayo dyan ba’t ang kanta ni Rosita jukebox at lahat ng scholars ay rock songs ano bayan PDA dapat patas lang ang laban, nakakawalang gana nang panourin kasi parang alam mo na kong sino ang mananalo, sana hindi nalang sila nagcontest kong ganon malang ang mangyayari. kong ganon sana pinasali nila yong mahihirap nalang lahat. kasi yong may talent na medyo may kaya parang wala namang chance.
    Kainiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiis!!!!!!

  4. Mary Ann Lubrica said:

    Dubai Rulez pare-pareho tayo ng comment kahit kami dito sa Kuwait lahat kami against sa ginagawa ng mga PDA Teachers & Jurors. Pati na rin yong mga kaibigan namin na Nurses din sa London & Dubai ganun din ang comment nila.. Bakit daw si Rosita pinapaboran..Dapat
    maging Fair sila sa iba na andoon sa loob kc lahat sila may gustong maabot. Sana naman ang karapadapat ay depende sa performance wag sana yong status ng buhay like Rosita. Pinapaboran siya dahil mahirap, katulong at bread winner sana labas na yan Kung ganun noong UMPISA PA LANG SINABI NILA AGAD NA DAPAT ANG SUMALI AY MGA MAHIHIRAP, BREAD WINNER ets. Wag nyo siyang igaya ke Nora Aunor na galing sa hirap pero naging Superstar. Si ate Guy talagang magaling the BEST OF ALL THE BEST during her time. Nobody made her Superstar due to poverty. She made herself Superstar because she’s great singer & actress. Anong say nyo???

    Request : PLS. LET ROSITA SING ALSO ROCK…

  5. Donna said:

    Dubai rulez - tama ka! i read in another forum that they’re trying to make rosita into another nora aunor…hahaha seriously…i think that’s very funny…i’m not surprised though…everything that abs-cbn does is all for business…i don’t have anything against rosita - she’s very entertaining to watch i admit haha but everything is all business related because they’re still trying to beat the gma (they still have the highest ratings) Look at PBB teen edition: KIMERALD is a BIIIIG hit, aldred, matt evans…more…some of the other kids aren’t very talnted but…who cares? they’re giving ABS-CBN moneeeey and ratings…

    here’s the successful 6:

    1. yeng: #1 song - good press for channel 2, can write very good songs, has a distinctive voice, has the complete package…and her love team with rj is HUGE

    2. yvan: very talented - just like yeng…my top boy
    3. ronnie: kumbaga “sex on a stick” and sex sells, di ba? very reminicent of sam milby…
    4. jay-r…just like ronnie…can sing and has many female fans….also the jay-r/iya love team
    5. chad: foreign guy in the PI is an instant hit - PLUS he is pure filipino who is pogi…can speak tagalog…he just needs to improve a little
    6. rosita…the next “nora” enough said

    plz tell me what you guys think - i’m curious :)

  6. diana grace abanero said:

    i was very disappointed with the teachers when they gave jay-r a grade of 6 while rosita got 8,magaling ba si rosita kesa kay jay-r o kay yeng?jay-r gave the very great voice with the song, pati anak ko napahiyaw when he heard jay-r sang it,ang galing daw ni Jay-r tapos magiging probe siya? unfair!!!

  7. ice said:

    unfair nga kinis! He deserve to be in the top 10! a hul package, he has the talent, the looks,the story and of course the fans!

  8. tfc subscriber said:

    Let’s admit it, Rosita is fun to watch. ABS is keeping her for the sake of tv ratings. People dont really want her to win, but they want to watch her. Proof is never pa syang nkakuha ng highest text votes, na-save lang sya lagi ng teachers. And PDA will be boring kung wala si Rosita. What will happen kung sina Joan at Davey at Yvan lang ang maiwan sa house? Boring?
    Jay-R was very good last Sat. The judge even pointed this out. But ABS needs to ensure if he is a potential moneymaker. Does he have the followers? His nomination is some sort of a test to see how strong his following is.
    Joan is good walang duda. but good singing alone cannot guarantee na bebenta ang album. Look what happen to Bituin or Dessa?
    Irish has the making of the next soap opera contravida.
    Yeng should stop being OA. People already know she is a good singer, hindi na kailangang magpapansin.

  9. Jenny Campuz said:

    Unfair talaga.. Luto na ang PDA …Pero si Rosita sana she must ask herself or her colleagues na “Bakit ikaw
    mababa ang grade mo sa akin eh mahirap yong kinanta mo samantala ako Diva na kayang-kaya nyo o bakit ka na nominate di ako… Dapat ganun din siya.. 2 weeks ago Yvan was nominated and Eman was blaming himself because they sung together “duet”, the Juror’s comment was Eman performed better in dancing than Yvan. He really did’nt accept the comment because he knew very well that Yvan is a good dancer than him.
    Dapat ganun din si Rosita… Hindi eh tuwang tuwa siya…. Walang pakiramdam…

  10. edson said:

    Sabi sa inyo scripted ito, syempre yung mabenta ang papapanalunin, si rosita pinapaboran dahil kinakaawan sya ng mga tao at pinapanood, dapat dito wowowee, star search edition!

  11. Dubai Rulez said:

    un nga e kinaaawaan si Rosita kaya dapat mahihirap nalang ang isinali.. salamat sa mga pumabor sa sinabi ko.. nung una fan ako ni rosita pero nitong mga tumagal e wala na…

    may nagsbi kung wala si Rosita boring ang PDA… ( tama ba sya?! )

    Enwei nahalata nyo ba na ayaw na ng mga colleagues ni rosita sa kanya.. (ako halata ko)

    honestly sobrang galing ni jay-r sa kanta nya..
    sobrang taas and kakaiba..

    hay rosita bareng…..
    ilang magagaling paba ang mwawala dahil sa mga naaawa sayo…

    peace out..

  12. Dubai Rulez said:

    Sandali lang!

    Nyonarians ba ung nakita ko sa plakard nung Saturday??!!??
    Hhhhhmmm………

    Kwawa si Nora Aunor…

    Well what can i say to the jurors….:-?
    baka nga tama ung sinabi ni kabayan na sa bandang huli hindi si rosita ang mananalo kung baga she’s fun to be watch DAW kaya they keeping rosita alive and the rest e paalam na sa pangarap nila dahil si rosita ay kasaya sayang panoorin DAW..

    Honestly nakakaawa naman si rosita dahil sa status nya sa buhay pero dapat ang gawin ng ABS CBN e paalisin si rosita dyan at gawing artista na lang pra tuloy ang pera nya, mas nakakaawa kasi ung mga natatanggal dahil lamang sa naaawa ke rosita eh…

  13. dianne of Iloilo said:

    i watch pda everynight b’coz of my kababayan Eman,and Jay-r and Chad..oa na ang dating ni rosita, feeling nya shes a great singer,sana wag na syang i-save ng mga teachers,mag-artista na lang sya as younger sister ni pokwang, hindi sya bagay sa pda, naawa ako last night kay Jay-r, he was crying na baka hindi nya makaya..dont worry Jay-r we’re to support you.Unfair lang talaga ang mga judges na nagbigay sa yo ng grade na 6,ang galing ng boses mo kesa kay rosita at saka bat ang low ng grade ni yeng last saturday?to think kalibre nya ang rock?hay, sana kumuha ang pda ng mas marunong magjudge…

  14. ciulaw said:

    nalungkot at nainis ako sa result last sat. jay-r gave a good performance and the judges gave him a shocking grade of 6.54. WTF!!! bat ba nagpadala ang mga judges sa gusto ng mga producers ng PDA? dahil gusto nila dag-dag kita dahil madami ang bubuto kay Jay-r, irish at jo-an. so this would mean this show is not a contest at all. what i see is that nanggagamit na naman sila para may pagkakitaan imbis na tulongan ang mga tao na may talent ma harness at ma-improve kung ano mayron cla.WTF talaga

  15. ciulaw said:

    if i was right the right ranking last sat would be
    1. panky
    2. yvan
    3. jay-r
    4. chad
    5. yeng
    6. emman
    7. jo-an
    8. ronnie
    9. rosita
    10 davey
    11. irish
    !!!No consistency tlga. ba’t di rcok ang kanta ni rosita. di fair sa lahat. i think one of the scholars should stand up about this even the teachers of the academy should voice out their concerns about this. wa’g na kayong magpadala sa gusto ng mga bigatin ng ABS.

  16. Donna said:

    HEY! Is it me or do you notice tha rosita is getting special treatment? Since when did she perform more at mall shows? Usually it’s the songwriters that go, right? Yeng, Yvan, Eman, Chad, etc…AND Rosita also got to go to Vilma’s birthday celebration…AND the dance teacher is giving Rosita her own dance number with the boys - “Santa Baby”…this is very sneaky ABS-CBN…can someone say “rigged”

    TELL ME WHAT YOU GUYS THINK!

  17. japoy said:

    maganda sana ang pda kaso d maganda ang bias……….

  18. japoy said:

    competion will always be a competition, if ur nt dcrvng u’ll be out

  19. ciulaw said:

    lulalaki na ang ulo ni rosita. ts ts ts. hinay hinay lang rosing. baka ka ma-untog at mabasag ang napakalaki mong ulo. bias tlga. think of it. if rosita gets out of the academy, di naman cya magiging singer, kundi kapalit ni pokwnag

  20. crazyover_ldw said:

    yeah… it’s really unfair!!! kahit si ronnie na nd rocker and si joan kahit nd bagay sa boses nya ang rock… nag-rock…pero si Rosita… ewan… kainis talaga… hay, finifilter ba ng pda staff ung mga letter for the scholars? gusto ko kasi sulatan si rosita…

  21. jLO said:

    So all of them did rock. Nakita naman na hindi bagay sa iba. My question is why is it every week Panky does a rock song. She has not sung a ballad. I wonder if she will do well doing Celine Dion. Eman too is also a rocker. Davey has to stop smiling. He is getting predictable. kahit anong kantahin niya he has a big smile and he always has to move his head around. Its like one of those dash board puppies that you see in the cars. Ronnies too stiff. Irish is trying too hard and then messes up on the ending. Joan looks like shes always coming after you with her mouth when she sings. Yengs trying to hypnotize people with her eyes. Shes going for the cute look. Chads facial expression always comes across too strong and his lips get too stiff and small.

    RJ is at ease on stage. Hindi bagay sakanya yung last song but he did well. They all need to work on their facial expressions and body movements. Its mostly too much, too little, or it dies off.

  22. Unknown said:

    I like the idea of having new judges every week. I actually agree with the judges choosing Irish, JayR and Davey for this week’s probation but thought Joan sang better than Rosita. Why I think that the three scholars I’ve mentioned deserved the nomination because Irish sang badly at the end, all the songs that Jay-R sing sounds the same (I wanted him to sing ballad for once)and Davey’s singing was affected when he sang and played his guitar at the same time which resulted him to concentrate more on playing his guitar well and less on singing his song.
    What I noticed about last week’s probation was, they chose a song that wasn’t rock for Rosita to sing and she was the only one who wore a dress while everyone else wore something that rockers might wear.

  23. dianne of Iloilo said:

    pansin ko nga na pda staff specially favored rosita,ung birit nya every saturday was not good,hindi sya pwedeng ihanay sa mga birit stars..sana mamulat ang mga judges this saturday that rosita sings lousy. kung ganyan din lang pala na they are favoring the likes of rosita sana pinili na lang nila lahat ng dh all over the pinas and the world…

  24. Dubai Rulez said:

    Kasi nga DAW pag nawala si Rosita sa PDA mwawalan nang gana DAW ang mga manood.

    I wonder……… hhhmm…

  25. Marie said:

    i wonder what the real reason is y rosita got expelled? whatever the case maybe i think it was wrong for them to ask her to exit that way. the others left the academy with grace..and why does she have to leave the way they asked her to..as if she’s a criminal or something that all of a sudden just left. you know what i mean? i don’t know.. what do you guys think?

  26. kairiyui said:

    talagang unfair ang pda!! obvious na obvious n c rosita ang gusto nila.. basta all i can is good luck to irish. she’s really pretty and talented

  27. Marie said:

    ok my bad..she wasn’t expelled at all..they played a trick on her..

    is it true that she’s being groomed as the next nora aunor? kindda hard to fill in that shoes since she has proven so much in her time..but watever.

    good luck pda scholars!

  28. pretty said:

    rosita..isn’t that name makes you laugh for awhile and suddenly makes you irritated and vice versa inside the pda…to all the scholar she’s the clown na may makapal na make-up…even though she was not expelled from the academy..atleast she still stands for it…to yeng…i really appreciate your performance and your voice..to ronnie…my kiliti kang pinapadama ehh…to jay-ar and emman..mga kalog..irish…i love you and your character..kay panky…naaaahhh…to joan…ewan…you’ve got a nice voice…kay yvan and davey..go go go..lalaingen nyo nga duwwa…hope this competition will bring you success…Goodluck!!!!

  29. andre said:

    haaaaaay sana manominate uli si rosita! ! ! ! ! !

  30. amy buen said:

    I am kind of worried what would be the outcome of the next nomination for PDA scholars nominated for expulsion with the new ruling. What really be sad is if the contestant came from a place where they couldn’t afford to do that texting because they don’t have any cell phone or prepaid phone cards or doesn’t have any means to send in their votes. Isn’t that would be hard for other contestants if that would be the case? So this will mean that there will be no more jurors to rate them because the winner will depend on the text votes. In a way, that will also be good since sometimes your jurors are so “brutal” with their comments that makes the contestants to feel really depressed and lowers their morals and self-esteem. Well, good luck to all the contestants, may the best one win. Just wondering how that Panky always becomes the “star” all she sings is just rock, wonder how she gonna perform any ballad songs.

  31. Danielle said:

    Mali ang Comment ng mga Judge…. Bkit naman napunta c Yeng sa Top 10… That was not fair… Ginawa naman nya ung best nya… mas magaling pa sya sa mga ibang scholar na nasa mas mataas na top position…

  32. ciulaw said:

    try to open your heart and open your mind, and you will know why panky always named the star scholar. it’s the talent, yes the talent that’s inside her

  33. ciulaw said:

    yap, yeng shouldn’t be in the bottom 4

  34. ciulaw said:

    EMAN SHOULD BE IN THE BOTTOM 4 AND IRISH

  35. Donna said:

    YENNNG???! Why is she in the bottom 4? Barbara Streisand is very hard to sing…yeng wasn’t the best 0 she didn’t sing it “better’ than Barbara…but she did a good job…i hope she stays in the academy

  36. ciulaw said:

    when yeng perfomed. it felt like i was already watching an artist outside the academy. it was a great performance. the whole family liked it. i guess yeng did justice to it

  37. dubai said:

    yeah oo nga, dpat tlga nde ksali si yeng sa bottom 4 kze compared sa ibang piece mahirap ung sa knya,dpat si irish ang kasali kze wla naman bago dun sa gnwa nya.

  38. novem monieva said:

    i want yvan to win on dream nigth,kasi lahat ng katangian ng isang singer na kay yvan na.gwapo,magaling,at higit sa lahat di mayabang,for yeng naman sikat ka na sana lang di mag sawa ang mga viewers sayo!!!rosita maganda ang boses mo pero bagsak ka sa star quality…panky galing mo.ronie sobrang gwapo mo nailigtas ka ng taong bayan.pero di bagay sayo ang rock music.emman go go go kaya mo yan susuportahan ka ng mga taga ilo ilo.good luck scholars pda is # 1

  39. jepers said:

    haleeerz…hahahai idol tlaga kta jay-r da best ka tlaga lahat ng katangian ng isang lalaki na sau na…kumbaa ur so much talented talag…i wish u win the PDA,deservng ka namn manalo…im crazy tlaga sau…lagi kng pinkinggan ung kanta mo ug NGLBOG/…hahahai sarap sa tinga..ur the star JAY_R

  40. lyn said:

    gwapo mo JAY-r dont u worry masasama ka sa top 6 we will support u specially in cbu..xempre kababayan e…kamukha mo pa nman c mark herras but infrness mas pogi ka at talented pa….u so much scrambled my life.hehehehe…..stay gud ..be confident ..of urself yan ang phunan mo sa un mga dreams …ur a star scholar jay-r

  41. nasty said:

    hahahai rosita ang drama mo tlaga …para lang kaawaan ka ng mgas tao….sorrybut ur not deserving sa pda…ur out…hindi sa pangit ka thats true…wahahah….ang oa mo tlaga….mtagal ka sanang na expledd kond lang dahil sa mga teacher….im xur ma out ka…di ka susuportahan ng mgatso nohhhh…wer waisting our loadd 4 voting uuu/

  42. julia said:

    VOTE FOR YENG CONSTANTINO!

  43. claudia said:

    hi..ang gwapo2 tlaga ni sam milby..sana mkita ko xia

  44. quennie said:

    ang cute m tlga jay _r sna wish ko lng n mkita ule kta and keep up a god work ……sna hiling ko n mag lbas k ule ng bagong cd kse i love your cd n hiling ….. i love u po ……ingat prte……

  45. jelly delator said:

    gwapo talaga ni jay-r kaya nga crush ko siya eh!!!!!!

  46. MaRieL_ShieLa_fOoK_ said:

    .wui!! aNg GwapO TaLaGa Ni JaY-R SiaBoC!!! OMG!!!
    MaS LaLO TaLaGa akonG NaGwa-GwaPuhaN Sa KanYa KaPaG NaPaPanOoD kO aNg TeLeSeRyE Na PanGaRaP Na BiTuiN!! LaLonG-LaLo Na’T PaReS NiYa Si MaJa SaLvadOr(My IDOL!),,,
    NaKu NaMaN!!,,,, I CaN’t uNdeRsTanD!?,, aDd Me NaLanG Sa fRieNdTeR kO!!…. odette_shiela@yahoo.com,,, WeLcOmE pOh Kau Dun!!!


Your Comments


Pinoy Dream Academy: Yeng Constantino + RJ Jimenez | Home | PMPC Star Awards for TV 2006 Winners